Summary
In its Media and Digital Platforms Market Inquiry, the Competition Commission concluded that structural remedies in advertising technology "are unlikely to attract buyers and competition given the small market size" (¶333). It chose instead to extend to South Africa the remedies imposed on Google in the European Union and the United States (Annexure 8, clause 8). Google may apply to vary that extension where a remedy is "not suitable for implementation in South Africa" (clause 8.4(i)).
This paper argues that AI agents buying media weaken the small-market premise. The Commission should bear that in mind when remedies from the EU arrive.
Findings
- The premise in ¶333 is the most likely ground for a future variation. An application to narrow an EU remedy in South Africa could rely on the Commission's own reasoning, without new evidence.
- The cost of reaching buyers is part of the cost of entry. Alongside production scale and network effects, the cost of finding, contracting with, settling with and proving delivery to buyers has been paid separately by each entrant in South Africa.
- Agentic buying moves that cost into shared infrastructure. When agents buy over a shared protocol, most of the cost of reaching buyers is paid once, not by each entrant for each buyer. This lowers the market size needed to support entry.
- Demand is no longer "the SA market alone". Agents acting for advertisers elsewhere in Africa can reach South African inventory, including community media, screens and newsletters that programmatic channels do not reach.
- A credible alternative can weaken Google's network effects. Findings 3 and 4 give publishers and advertisers a route to each other that does not depend on South African market size alone.
- The mechanism is conditional. It depends on agent protocols remaining open and interoperable, on agents not steering demand toward their providers, and on agents reaching Google Ad Manager inventory. Where these conditions fail, the premise in ¶333 may still hold.
- The route already exists. The Commission's remedial actions already provide for EU outcomes to reach South Africa. What is needed is scrutiny of any attempt to narrow them.
What the paper asks
When interoperability remedies from the European Commission's ad-tech case (AT.40670) are extended to South Africa, the Commission should ensure they are not narrowed in a way that excludes AI agents acting for buyers and sellers. If the EU outcome expressly gives agents access, the Commission should extend it without dilution. In both cases, access should be neutral as to which open agent protocol is used, and should include inventory sold through Google Ad Manager. The paper does not ask the Commission to reopen the Inquiry or to impose new remedies.
What's inside
- Executive summary
- 1. The finding we are responding to
- 2. Why the premise held
- 3. What changes when agents buy
- 4. The risks, stated plainly
- 5. What this means for remedies
- 6. A working example
- About this paper
- References (35 sources)
The full paper sets out the evidence, the risks and 35 references, drawn from a literature search of about 630 results. Paragraph and clause numbers refer to the Commission's non-confidential Final Report and Annexure 8.
Interest and status
This paper is published by Diretsa, an agent-bookable marketplace for South African media, which has an interest in the outcome it argues for. It has not been commissioned or funded by any other party. Diretsa appears in section 6 as a working example, not as evidence of scale, and will make its underlying booking data available to the Commission on a confidential basis: write to support@diretsa.com.
This paper reflects information available on 19 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Statements about procedure under the Commission's remedial actions represent the author's reading of Annexure 8. It was prepared with the assistance of an AI model (Claude, by Anthropic); the author reviewed it and is responsible for the analysis, sources and conclusions.
Cite this paper
Zvobwo, E. C. (2026). Too small to matter? AI agents, open protocols and the MDPMI ad-tech remedies. Diretsa white paper, 19 November 2026. https://diretsa.com/research/too-small-to-matter
